Travis Scott’s Astroworld Festival tragedy is a symptom of hip hop’s new punk phase

Travis Scott’s Astroworld Competition was a catastrophe, a morbid one. What was alleged to be the exaltation of fifty,000 individuals raging final Friday night time was eclipsed by the loss of life of eight individuals within the crowd.

When the hip-hop star appeared on stage in Houston, the gang surged towards the entrance, resulting in chaos and finally casualties. He, shock visitor performer Drake and live performance promoter Stay Nation are now under investigation and have been sued.

Scott’s live shows are sometimes electrical, buzzing with vitality, however they’ve by no means escalated to this degree, and sadly this tragedy is a symptom of rap’s adoption of punk sensibilities.

Hip-hop live shows right now are a lot totally different than within the days of yore. Those that smoked and bopped to beats within the Nineties have been swept away and changed by the non secular descendants of followers down the corridor: punks. Simply to the left of the tame fandoms of rappers comparable to Drake, J. Cole and Kendrick Lamar are the gang surfers, stage divers, moshers and ragers within the crowds of a brand new breed of performers, headed Tyler the Creator, A$AP Rocky, Trippie Redd, Playboi Carti and Scott.

Their music is visceral in the identical method punk was. The lyrics get followers charged up, and the instrumentals do the remaining. As an alternative of the mesmerizing lyrics, stunning melodies or rhythm that had been as soon as most popular by rap followers, they now rage on vitality alone. When Tyler the Creator chanted, “Kill individuals, burn shit, fuck college,” within the hook of his song Radicals in 2011, it was anthemic and the soundtrack to raging for an evolving style and new technology.

A part of the explanation the rabid fandom of punk, steel and now rap stay up for reside reveals is as a result of they’re exhilarating. Opposite to Drake within the 2010s, the punk aesthetic of XXXTentacion’s Look At Me! and Scott’s No Bystanders felt practically countercultural. Buying and selling slickness and sensuality for discord and chaos was and nonetheless is elating. The power to utterly launch your physique and feelings is cathartic, and doubly so for a rager who has been cooped up of their home for greater than a 12 months due to the pandemic.

However the distinction between the Astroworld Competition and former reveals is that the chaos was uncontrolled. What occurred at Astroworld was a departure from the punk tradition. Rooted in punk and steel reveals was a way of etiquette and security that took years to develop after the AC/DC and Weapons N’ Roses crowd crushes. This etiquette hasn’t totally crossed over with right now’s rap followers or artists.

Individuals who died at Astroworld had been as younger as 14, and a 9 12 months previous was critically injured. Scott offers with a crowd younger sufficient to have learn in regards to the overcrowded and violent Woodstock ‘99 competition in a textbook somewhat than to have lived its horrifically comparable expertise.

The unwritten guidelines of punk areas – if somebody falls, decide them up; shoulders, no elbows; don’t pull individuals into the fray – predate the individuals who occupy them now, and it’s a part of the explanation why ragers had been jumping on emergency vehicles as first responders had been making an attempt to are likely to these in want.

And to high it off, Scott encourages the mayhem. On the Lollapalooza competition in 2015, Scott was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct after inciting followers to disregard safety and rush the stage. In 2017, after a efficiency in Arkansas, he was arrested once more and charged with inciting a riot. In a now deleted tweet, after promoting out Astroworld, Scott mentioned the competition was going to sneak in additional individuals.

Mayhem has all the time been the bedrock of Scott’s stardom however that doesn’t excuse his lack of care. The performer occupies a bully pulpit throughout his present, and what he says may imply the distinction between life and loss of life for followers. Others within the house have been cautious, and have been applauded. A$AP Rocky, one of many pioneers of hip hop’s punkness, halted his Rolling Loud efficiency in 2019 to make sure fallen people got picked up.

And Playboi Carti did the same simply this summer season at Lollapalooza when he was notified of individuals passing out, explicitly saying, “I care about you guys, security first.”

Astroworld is what occurs when punk is stripped all the way down to merely the aesthetic with out its tradition. It’s huge, it’s loud, and the gang is a swarming ball of vitality. Performing in entrance of and being part of that ball of vitality is completely enthralling, however with out the power to actually harness that vitality whereas always stoking it’s going to solely result in tragedy.

Sign up for The Globe’s arts and way of life newsletters for extra information, columns and recommendation in your inbox.